About
the Majors Programs at the United States Naval Academy
Having been tasked by Andy Wehrle to prepare a position paper regarding
the USNA Academic Majors program to provide the necessary education for
the future core combat leaders of the Naval Services, we [CAPT Deke Forbes,
USN (Ret) and RADM Ken Haynes, USN (Ret)] have been involved in a review
of the current and past academic programs at USNA.
Since there appears to be considerable misunderstanding of the USNA Majors
Program among those who graduated prior to 1967, we thought it best to
first provide this paper, which describes the academic program of the
`30's through the mid 60's, the so called "lock-step" program,
and the current academic program, The Majors.
ACADEMIC PROGRAM 1930'S-1966
The program was a "one fits all curriculum" where all midshipmen
followed the same curriculum for four years with the only variable being
the foreign language selected. In summary, each midshipman had to successfully
complete the following academic program:
- two years of math through differential equations
- one year of chemistry
- one year of physics
- two years of foreign language
- many courses over four years in English, History and Government, Electrical
Engineering, Marine Engineering, Ordnance and Gunnery, Seamanship and Navigation,
and Leadership--too numerous to list here
There were no provisions for validating courses for those who had previous
college level education and those who successfully passed Calculus, and advanced
Chemistry and Physics, in High School. As a result, those who had passed certain
college and some high school level level courses were required to retake the
same courses at USNA.
Common exams in each subject were administered classwide at the end of each
semester. Daily recitation grades in each course were the norm. Those who failed
a course based on a combination of daily grades and the final exam, barring
a reexam offered by the Academic Board, were dismissed from the Academy for
"academic reasons." A reexam, if offered, was taken within a few days
after appearance before the Academic Board. Failure of the reexam, barring the
granting of a re-reexam by the Board, resulted in dismissal also. In some instances,
midshipmen who were deemed to be so deserving, were "turned back"
to the USNA Class behind them.
Since the course content was uniform for all classes taking that course, the
course was pitched in level of difficulty to the average midshipman, often leaving
the more academically gifted without a significant academic challenge in that
course.
All midshipmen who successfully completed the four year program (three years
for Classes of 1942 through 1948A) were conferred a Bachelor of Science degree
(undesignated) as authorized by an Act of Congress.
Management and oversight of the academic program were in the hands of senior
naval officers, usually a Captain, holding positions as Secretary of the Academic
Board, Department Heads for MATH/ELECTRICAL ENGINEERING/MARINE ENGINEERING/ORDNANCE&GUNNERY/SEAMANSHIP&
NAVIGATION/ENGLISH, HISTORY&GOVERNMENT, and FOREIGN LANGUAGES.
The faculty was split about 50-50 between civilian professors and military
instructors. There was no academic dean.
The advantages and disadvantages of the old academic program are opined to
be:
ADVANTAGES
- Simplicity of operation and administration
- Uniform approach to determining academic standing among peers, with
concomitant impact on future lineal number in the USN
- Quality and depth of education based on curriculum offered was uniform
DISADVANTAGES
- No validation of previous college or certain high school courses passed
was allowed with concomitant inefficient use of time and lack of academic challenge
to those midshipmen with varying amounts of college level, and some high school
level, experience (most notably in math, science, English and foreign languages)
- Course content and level of difficulty were aimed at the average midshipman
with concomitant lack of academic challenge to many more academically gifted
students
- inefficient preparation of some who sought postgraduate education in
engineering and science disciplines under USN auspices through failure to provide
many undergraduate courses necessary to fulfillment of the graduate degree.
The consequence--about three years devoted to postgraduate education to obtain
an undergraduate degree and a Masters degree in those disciplines with significant
affect on time away from the operational venue
- accessions impact on potential candidates, particularly those with
college level experience, who preferred to either pursue designated degrees
or not have to repeat courses they had already mastered
- significant academic attrition due to quick reexams for those who failed
subjects, who in most instances were not prepared academically to pass the reexam.
The "lock step" program did not have the flexibility to repeat a course
in its entirety except under the "turnback" option.
THE MAJORS PROGRAM (1967-today)
The Academic organization, headed by an Academic Dean (previously
a civilian academician but currently a USNA graduate with significant
academic administration background), consisting of four academic Divisions
headed by a senior naval officer (usually a Captain), is constituted today
as follows:
ENGINEERING/WEAPONS DIVISION
- Aerospace Engineering Department
- Electrical Engineering Department
- Mechanical Engineering Department
- Naval Architecture and Ocean Engineering Department
- Weapons and Systems Department
MATH/SCIENCE DIVISION
- Chemistry Department
- Math Department
- Computer Science Department
- Physics Department
- Oceanography Department
- Quantitative Economics Department
HUMANITIES/SOCIAL SCIENCE DIVISION
- Economics Department
- English Department
- History Department
- Language Studies Department
- Political Science Department
PROFESSIONAL DEVELOPMENT DIVISION
- Leadership, Ethics, and Law Department
- Seamanship and Navigation Department
The various "majors" made available to midshipmen, as well as the
advent of the majors program, was initiated during the tour of VADM Calvert
when he was the Superintendent.
The Majors Program today consists of the following "MAJORS" (Note:
an * asterisk indicates that a designated degree--such as BS Aero Eng or BS
Computer Science--is offered for those majors only)
DIVISION I MAJORS
* Aerospace Engineering
* Electrical Engineering
General Engineering
* Mechanical Engineering
* Naval Architecture
* Ocean Engineering
* Systems Engineering |
DIVISION II MAJORS
* Chemistry
* Computer Science
General Science
Mathematics
Oceanography
Physics
Quantitative
Economics |
DIVISION III MAJORS
Economics
English
History
Political Science |
General Engineering and General Science majors may be elected by midshipmen.
These majors are also `fallback" for those who originally select
other majors but, for whatever reason, are not able to continue to pursue
the major originally selected.
CURRICULA REQUIREMENTS
All Plebes must complete a common 4/c academic year. The requirements are
shown later. Curricula for 3/c, 2/c, 1/c vary depending on the major selected.
The course requirements for each major fall into three areas:
- CORE---essential to every midshipman's education regardless of major selected
- DIVISION---common to all majors within a Division
- MAJOR---prescribed set of courses necessary for the designated degree
CORE COURSES
These CORE requirements apply to all majors:
- Mathematics--three semesters of calculus plus either a course in differential
equations or probability and statistics. Those who can validate take higher
level course
- Chemistry---One year of chemistry. Those who can validate take higher level
courses
- Physics---One year of Physics. Those who can validate take electives
- Engineering---All Division I majors, as well as Math/Physics/Chemistry majors,
must take two electrical engineering and two systems engineering courses.
All Division II and III majors must complete two courses in Naval Engineering.
All Division III majors, plus Computer Science/General Science/Oceanography/
Quantitative Economics must take three integrated electrical/weapons engineering
courses.
- English---All are required to take a two course sequence in English. Those
needing additional preparation must take "Practical Writing." Validators
take advance courses in English.
- History---All are required to take a course in American Naval Heritage and
a two course sequence in History of Western Civilization.
- Writing---The two course sequence in both English and History require significant
amounts of writing. If a midshipman is deemed deficient in writing at the
completion of those course sequences, he may be required to take an additional
course, "Professional Writing."
- Government---All are required to take a course in American government and
constitutional development.
- Humanities/Social Sciences---All midshipman requires 24 semester hours of
core courses in this area. The English, History and Government courses specified
above count towards the 24 hours requirement. Additionally, two Humanities/
Social Science electives are required.
- Languages---All Division III majors must complete or validate 4 semesters
of a foreign language.
- Professional---All majors must take three specified Naval Science courses,
a specified Navigation course, two specified Leadership courses, and a specified
Ethics Course. Professional courses cannot be validated.
COMMON PLEBE YEAR ACADEMIC COURSES
- Leadership and Human Behavior
- Fundamentals of Naval Science.
- U. S. Government and Constitutional Development
- American Naval Heritage
- Two semesters of calculus of varying difficulty dependent on validation/
placement examinations.
- Two semesters of chemistry of varying difficulty dependent on validation
and placement examinations.
- Two semesters of English.
GRADUATION REQUIREMENTS
- Complete or validate the core, divisional and majors courses specified
in the course matrix for each major.
- Complete or validate a minimum of 140 semester hours, including a
minimum of 90 hours in the CORE program with a cumulative quality point rating
(CQPR) of 2.0 (Note: Quality points for each course taken are awarded as follows:
A=4; B=3; C=2; D=1; F=0).
DEGREES
All those who complete the course of instruction and become graduates receive,
as a minimum, a Bachelor of Science Degree (undesignated) as provided for by
an Act of Congress. Those who successfully complete the requirements for a designated
degree (e.g. BS Aero Engineering or BS Computer Science) are awarded a specific
degree in that major. There are no Bachelor of Art degrees or designated degrees
in non-asterisk majors (e.g. English, History, Political Science, Math, Physics,
etc.)
SUMMER ACADEMIC PROGRAM
Midshipmen attend summer school for a variety of reasons. Some volunteer in
order to move ahead in their major to take additional elective courses, and
some try to improve their QPR by repeating courses where they were given a "D"
grade. These volunteers attend during their summer leave program.
Those midshipmen who have failed a course, fall behind in their major matrix,
change majors, or have a low CQPR (< 2.0), may be directed by the Academic
Board or Academic Advisory Board to attend summer school to take, in many cases,
a different course in order to open a hole in the next semester schedule to
repeat the course that was failed. Attendance of those directed to summer school,
which is mandatory, may preclude participation in some aspects of summer professional
training programs as well as summer leave.
VALIDATION
Validation and placement take place during Plebe Summer at the request of the
individual midshipman to the cognizant Department Head(s) of the course(s) he
wants to try to validate.
The advantages and disadvantages of the "majors program" are opined
as follows:
ADVANTAGES
- accession of potential candidates is improved by the availability of designated
degrees, validation, and choice of major even though the term "major"
is somewhat of a misnomer in that the overall curriculum for all is heavily
engineering and science oriented as it always has been.
- course content and degree of difficulty can be varied to meet the need of
a wide spectrum of academic ability with the concomitant effects that the
education level is expanded for the more academically gifted and all levels
of academic ability will be challenged
- provision for designated degrees in engineering and science permits those
who may seek postgraduate education under USN auspices in the same discipline
to complete their Masters degree program in about one year vice a nominal
three year program under the 'lock-step" program. This reduces time away
from the operational venue
- institution of the summer school program has reduced academic attrition
significantly and essentially removed the potential stigma associated with
the "turnback" midshipman. More importantly, it provides a midshipman
who has failed a course an opportunity to repeat that course in its entirety
with an extremely high rate of success, as opposed to the old "reexam"
approach which had a much lower rate of success
- elective courses are generally available to midshipmen in varying quantities,
all of which tend to broaden their knowledge and understanding in academic
areas of interest to the individual midshipman
DISADVANTAGES
- the operation and administration of the academic program is significantly
more complex that the older program
- the advent of the Academic Dean, with many of the trappings from academia
Most of the complaints heard from older graduates seem to focus on the "fact"
that USNA has English, History, Economics and Political Science "majors".
To put that in perspective for many of you, the following data is offered from
the curricula matrices for those majors:
| MAJOR |
CORE
SEM HRS |
MAJOR
SEM HRS
|
TOTAL |
| English |
110 |
30 |
140 |
| History |
110 |
30 |
140 |
| Poly Sci |
110 |
30 |
140 |
| Economics |
110 |
39 |
149 |
| TYPICAL CORE COURSES |
|
|
| SUBJECT |
TITLE |
YEAR |
APPLICABLE MAJOR |
| Math |
Calculus and Analytic Geometry I&II |
4/C |
ALL |
| Math |
Calculus III |
3/C |
ALL |
| Math |
Probability and Stats or Diff. Equations |
3/C |
ALL |
| Chemistry |
Foundations of Chemistry I&II |
4/C |
ALL |
| Physics |
General Physics I&II |
3/C |
ALL |
| Engineering |
Electrical Engineering I&II |
2/C; l/C |
DIV I plus Math, Chemistry, Physics |
| Engineering |
Naval Weapons Systems |
2/C |
same as above |
| Engineering |
Control Systems |
1/C |
same as above |
| Engineering |
Naval Engineering I&II |
2/C; l/C |
ALL DIV II/III |
| Engineering |
Intro. Electrical Technology |
2/C |
DIV III plus CompSci,Gen.Eng, Oceanography and Quant.
Economics |
| Engineering |
Intro. Wpns Systems Engineering |
2/C |
same as above |
| Engineering |
Weapons Systems Engineering |
1/C |
same as above |
| English |
Rhetoric and Literature I&II |
4/C |
ALL |
| History |
American Naval Heritage |
4/C |
ALL |
| History |
History of Western Civilization I&II |
3/C |
ALL |
| Government |
American Gov't & Constitutional Devel. |
4/C |
ALL |
| Humanities |
Two (2) Hum/Soc. Sci. electives |
2/C; l/C |
ALL |
| Language |
Four(4) semesters of one language |
4/C; 3/C |
ALL DIV III |
| Professional |
Fundamentals of Naval Science |
4/C |
ALL |
| Professional |
Tactics |
2/C |
ALL |
| Professional |
J.O Practicum (in service select. area) |
1/C |
ALL |
| Professional |
Navigation |
3/C |
ALL |
| Professional |
Leadership/Human Behavior |
4/C |
ALL |
| Professional |
Leadership: Theory and Practice |
2/C |
ALL |
| Professional |
Law for the Junior Officer |
1/C |
ALL |
| Professional |
Ethics and Moral Reasoning |
3/C |
ALL |
Notes: |
| (1) Few, if any, "majors" related courses
are taken until 2/c year, after the midshipman is committed to stay
at USNA |
| (2) All Engineering "majors", except EE, take
courses familiar to old grads, like Statics, Dynamics, Fluid Mechanics,
Thermodynamics and Materials |
| (3) There are some variations in the core courses
in Math, Chemistry, Physics and English dependent on validations and
placement exams |
| (4) The Junior Officer Practicum required in 1/c year
is a course in the duties and responsibilities expected of a junior
officer in his area of service selection |
All
USNA alumniactive duty, retired and civilian
are invited to
JOIN
the Concerned Alumni discussion.
|